Summary
No. In Tulum, a yearly lease keeps more than Airbnb in every area where we can compare.
A typical 85 m² 2-bed asks about US$920 a month on a yearly lease, according to MonadLuxury. After a month empty, building fees, property tax and the 25% tax of an owner living abroad, the lease keeps about 1.4% of the price, about US$280 a month.
The same flat on Airbnb takes in about US$5,340 a year at the median, according to AirROI, and loses about 1.5% of the price, about US$300 a month.
To keep what the lease keeps, Airbnb would need about 146 booked nights a year at the town's average rate. The median 2-bed books about 37.
The gap is smallest in Villas Tulum, 2.5 points, and widest in Aldea Tulum, 5.1 points, where the lease keeps 2.4%.
Yearly rents are falling too, about 5.8% a year. Even so, a tenant beats a holiday guest in Tulum today.
Our Tulum Airbnb versus yearly lease table by area
Our table compares what the same 85 m² 2-bed keeps on a yearly lease and on Airbnb in 8 areas of Tulum, after costs and tax. It gives our verdict, both net yields, the gap, the money kept each month, the Airbnb nights needed to match the lease and the nights booked today.
The first line is Tulum as a whole.
If you want real answers from the field about a specific home or street, ask a pro in Tulum for free.
| Area |
Which pays more? our short answer |
Rank 1 = Airbnb comes closestiThe 8 areas ranked on Airbnb minus the yearly lease. Every area gets the same verdict. |
Airbnb vs a Yearly Lease net yield after tax, in pointsiAirbnb net yield minus yearly-lease net yield, both after the 25% tax of an owner abroad, in points. |
Net Rental Yield yearly lease, after taxi(11 months of rent − 12 × building fees − 0.6% of the price for property tax and upkeep − 25% of the gross rent in tax) ÷ price. |
Net Rental Yield Airbnb with a manager, after taxi(AirROI median 2-bed takings × 0.70 for a manager, cleaning and platform − US$1,800 of utilities − 12 × building fees − 0.6% of the price − 25% of the takings in tax) ÷ price. |
Kept per Month yearly lease iYearly-lease income after building fees, upkeep, a month empty and tax, per month. |
Kept per Month Airbnb; − = a loss |
Nights Needed a year, to match the yearly leaseiBooked nights a year at which Airbnb keeps what the yearly lease keeps, at the AirROI 2-bed nightly rate. |
Nights Booked a year, median 2-bed, our estimate |
Monthly Rent 85 m² 2-bed, asking (MonadLuxury) |
Why what drives the verdict here |
Data confidence iHigh: direct data for this area. Medium: one strong source, or several pointing the same way, with our own estimate. Low: few signals, an order of magnitude. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TulumChecked Nov 2026 | Yearly lease | — | −2.9 pts | 1.4% | −1.5% | US$280 | −US$300 | 146 | ~37 | US$920 | A yearly lease keeps US$280 a month, Airbnb loses US$300. Airbnb would need about 146 booked nights a year to match the lease. The median 2-bed books about 37. | Medium |
| Aldea Zama | Yearly lease | =5 of 8 | −3.2 pts | 1.7% | −1.5% | US$340 | −US$300 | 158 | ~37 | US$1,010 | The best‑known planned area, paved, with the most homes for sale. The lease keeps US$340 a month. Airbnb loses US$300. | Medium |
| Centro Tulum | Yearly lease | 2 of 8 | −2.7 pts | 1.2% | −1.5% | US$250 | −US$300 | 141 | ~37 | US$880 | About 141 booked nights a year would match the lease here, far above the town's median listing. The town centre, where locals live and work. | Medium |
| Region 8 | Yearly lease | 3 of 8 | −2.8 pts | 1.3% | −1.5% | US$270 | −US$300 | 143 | ~37 | US$890 | A newer condo district north of town, roads still partly unpaved. Airbnb comes 2.8 pts short of a lease that keeps US$270 a month. | Low |
| Villas Tulum | Yearly lease | 1 of 8 | −2.5 pts | 1.0% | −1.5% | US$210 | −US$310 | 134 | ~37 | US$820 | An older locals' neighbourhood with houses and small blocks. The lease keeps US$210 a month. Airbnb loses US$310. | Medium |
| La Veleta | Yearly lease | 4 of 8 | −3.0 pts | 1.5% | −1.5% | US$280 | −US$300 | 145 | ~37 | US$910 | About 145 booked nights a year would match the lease here, far above the town's median listing. A lively area of cafés and condos, with dirt roads and power cuts. | Medium |
| Region 15 | Yearly lease | =5 of 8 | −3.2 pts | 1.7% | −1.5% | US$330 | −US$290 | 154 | ~37 | US$980 | The newest condo district, mostly unpaved, paving begun. Airbnb comes 3.2 pts short of a lease that keeps US$330 a month. | Medium |
| Tumben Kaa | Yearly lease | 7 of 8 | −4.6 pts | 2.4% | −2.2% | US$270 | −US$250 | 134 | ~37 | US$820 | A residential locals' area west of the centre. The lease keeps US$270 a month. Airbnb loses US$250. | Low |
| Aldea Tulum | Yearly lease | 8 of 8 | −5.1 pts | 2.4% | −2.7% | US$210 | −US$230 | 120 | ~37 | US$710 | About 120 booked nights a year would match the lease here, far above the town's median listing. A budget development: Cadu had sold 6,781 homes there by December 2025. | Medium |
Rule: Airbnb net yield minus yearly-lease net yield, both after the 25% tax of an owner living abroad, over +1 point = Airbnb, −0.2 to +1 = About the same, under −0.2 = Yearly lease. Within 0.05 point of a limit = Close call. Both sides use the same 85 m² 2-bed at MonadLuxury asking prices, the same building fees and property tax, and the same 25% tax on gross income for an owner living abroad. Airbnb also needs furniture (not counted) and far more of your time. Every area reads Yearly lease, which is the real answer. The rank shows where Airbnb comes closest. Tulum Beach, Cobá Road, Tulum Country Club, Holistika and Tankah have fewer than 10 flats for rent on MonadLuxury, so no rent. Selva Zama and Bahia Soliman are left out: MonadLuxury has no page for Selva Zama and only 8 condos for sale in Bahia Soliman, too few for a median.
How we got these numbers. We read MonadLuxury's market pages for Tulum and its neighbourhoods (asking prices, rents, listings and time on the market, 16 November 2026), Propiedades.com's price and rent changes by colonia, AirROI for holiday rentals, the income tax law and Banxico's exchange rate, and checked prices against Riviera Audit and Odigos. Takings and nightly rates are read as AirROI's dollar figures (its pesos ÷ 17.5, the rate AirROI converts at). Other pesos are converted at 18.55 per US$ (Banxico FIX, 13 Nov 2026).
Source: TheLatinvestor property database, November 2026.
Ask a local agent
in Tulum, for free.
They know what tenants really pay.
Message a proIs Airbnb better than a yearly lease in Tulum right now?
No. A yearly lease keeps more in every area where we can compare, and Airbnb loses money in all of them.
For the town, a typical 2-bed keeps about 1.4% of its price a year on a yearly lease, after costs and the 25% tax. On Airbnb, it loses about 1.5%. That is a gap of 2.9 points.
Our rule: Airbnb wins if it keeps more than 1 point above the lease, it is About the same between −0.2 and +1 point, and the Yearly lease wins below −0.2. Every area reads Yearly lease.
What does each option keep per month?
For the town's 2-bed at US$238K, a yearly lease keeps about US$280 a month and Airbnb loses about US$300.
The lease: about US$920 a month in rent, 11 months a year, about US$10,080. Building fees take about US$2,760 a year in our estimate, property tax and upkeep about US$1,430, and the 25% tax about US$2,520. That leaves about US$3,370.
Airbnb: the median 2-bed takes in about US$5,340. A manager, cleaning and the platform take about 30%, utilities about US$1,800 and the tax about US$1,330. Then the same building fees and property tax. That is a loss of about US$3,590.
The building fees and property tax are the same on both sides. What sinks Airbnb is that its takings are half a year's rent.
How many nights would Airbnb need to match the lease?
About 146 a year for the town, at AirROI's average 2-bed rate of US$142 a night. The median 2-bed books about 37.
By area, it runs from about 120 nights in Aldea Tulum, where rents are lowest, to about 158 in Aldea Zama, where they are highest.
Even a strong listing falls short. AirROI's average 2-bed took in about US$9,890 over the 12 months to October 2026, about 69 nights at the average rate.
Where does Airbnb come closest?
In Villas Tulum, where it trails the lease by 2.5 points. Rents there are low for the price: about US$820 a month on a US$250K flat, so the lease keeps only about 1.0%.
Centro Tulum comes next, 2.7 points behind, then Region 8 at 2.8 points and La Veleta at 3.0.
Close means less bad. In every one of these areas, Airbnb still loses about 1.5% of the price a year.
Ask a Tulum pro
today, for free.
They know the building rules and local permits.
Message a proWhere does the lease win by the most?
In the cheapest areas. In Aldea Tulum, the lease keeps about 2.4% and Airbnb loses 2.7%, a gap of 5.1 points. In Tumben Kaa, it is 2.4% against a loss of 2.2%.
Rents there are high for the price. A 2-bed asks about US$710 a month in Aldea Tulum on a US$103K flat, and US$820 in Tumben Kaa on a US$133K flat.
Airbnb's costs do not shrink with the price. Utilities and building fees are the same, so on a cheap flat they eat a larger share.
Are Tulum's yearly rents reliable?
They are asking rents, and they are falling. MonadLuxury lists 1,250 flats for rent in Tulum, with a median of MXN 200 per m² a month. A rental leaves the site after a median 98 days.
Propiedades.com, another portal, shows the town's average asking rent down 8.5% from May 2025 to November 2026, about 5.8% a year.
The two portals do not ask the same. Propiedades.com's median asking rent per m² is about 14% above MonadLuxury's in Aldea Zama, 12% in La Veleta and 32% in Tulum Centro. If tenants pay that much, the lease wins by more.
Does the 25% tax favour one or the other?
No, it hits both. Under article 158 of Mexico's income tax law, an owner who lives abroad pays 25% of the gross rent with no deduction, whether the tenant stays a year or a night. The law lets a non-resident choose 35% of the net profit instead.
Airbnb carries one more tax. Quintana Roo charges a 6% lodging tax on stays in private homes, which the platform withholds from the guest.
Before income tax, the town's 2-bed would keep about 2.5% on a lease and lose about 0.9% on Airbnb. The answer does not change.
What does our comparison leave out?
Furniture, and your time. Our yields assume the flat is already furnished on both sides.
Tulum Land & Property, a local agency, gave a budget of US$20,000 to US$30,000 to furnish a 2-bed in September 2026, appliances excluded. If you would let the flat unfurnished to a yearly tenant, the lease wins by more than our table shows.
Airbnb also needs someone to price nights, answer guests and handle cleaning every few days. A yearly tenant needs a contract and a deposit.
Ask a property manager
in Tulum, for free.
They find tenants, fix things and send reports.
Message a proDid the tourism slump tip the balance toward the lease?
It made Airbnb weaker. AirROI's average takings per listing fell 7.9% over the 12 months to October 2026.
Quintana Roo's tourism monitor puts Tulum hotel occupancy at 61.81% from January to August 2026, against 70.91% a year earlier. Obras Expansión reported a 14% fall in holiday-rental income in 2026, citing AirDNA.
The lease is not untouched. Fewer tourists mean fewer hospitality jobs, and yearly rents fell in every area with enough listings to tell. They still keep more than Airbnb.
So, is Airbnb better than long-term renting in Tulum?
No. A yearly lease keeps about 1.4% of a typical 2-bed's price after costs and tax, and Airbnb loses about 1.5%. Every area we can compare reads Yearly lease, from Villas Tulum, 2.5 points behind, to Aldea Tulum, 5.1 points behind.
The weakest part of our figures is that every area shares the town's median Airbnb takings. A standout flat will do better. To match the lease, it would need about 146 booked nights a year, four times what the median books.
If you buy to let in Tulum, a yearly tenant is the simpler and better choice today. Expect rents to keep slipping for now.
Our methodology
Our data runs through November 2026. We compare what an 85 m² 2-bed keeps on a yearly lease and on Airbnb, after costs and tax, in 8 areas of Tulum and the town as a whole.
We analyzed 130 sources and 669 signals on Tulum, including Airbnb data sites, property portals, the tax law, the state tourism monitor and the local press. The table itself uses 21 signals from 8 sources.
Rents and prices are MonadLuxury's median asking figures per m² for the area (16 November 2026), times 85 m². Airbnb takings are AirROI's median yearly takings of an entire 2-bed home in Tulum, 12 months to October 2026, the same for every area. Building fees are our estimate for the whole town, from listings.
The lease net yield is 11 months of rent, minus 12 months of building fees, minus 0.6% of the price, minus 25% of the rent in tax, divided by the price. The Airbnb net yield is the takings times 0.70, minus US$1,800 of utilities, minus the same fees and 0.6%, minus 25% of the takings, divided by the price. Airbnb takings and nightly rates are read as AirROI's dollar figures (its pesos ÷ 17.5, the rate AirROI converts at). Rents and other pesos are converted at the Banxico FIX of 13 November 2026.
Rule: Airbnb minus the lease over 1 point is Airbnb, from −0.2 to 1 point is About the same, under −0.2 is Yearly lease. Every area reads Yearly lease, so the rank shows where Airbnb comes closest.
Tulum Beach, Cobá Road, Tulum Country Club, Holistika and Tankah are left out: they have fewer than 10 flats for rent. Selva Zama and Bahia Soliman have too few condos for sale. This is general information built from public data, not personal financial advice.
Key sources used for this analysis include MonadLuxury: asking rents and prices per m², flats for rent and time to rent in Tulum, 16 November 2026, MonadLuxury: Villas Tulum asking prices and rents, MonadLuxury: Aldea Tulum asking prices and rents, AirROI: 2-bed median and average takings, nightly rate and takings trend in Tulum, 12 months to October 2026, Propiedades.com: Aldea Zama asking rent per m² and Tulum's rent change, May 2025 to November 2026, Propiedades.com: Tulum Centro asking rent per m², Propiedades.com: La Veleta asking rent per m², Article 158 of Mexico's income tax law: 25% of a non-resident's gross rent, or 35% of the net, Quintana Roo lodging tax law: 6% on stays in private homes, Tulum Land & Property: furnishing budget for a 2-bed, September 2026, Quintana Roo tourism monitor: Tulum hotel occupancy, January to August 2025 and 2026, Obras Expansión: holiday-rental income down 14% in 2026 and Banxico: FIX exchange rate, 13 November 2026.
Spotted an error? Tell us, we fix it within days.