Is it better to buy or rent in Cartagena now?

Get all the data you need about the real estate market in Cartagena

Why is buying versus renting in Cartagena such a hard call right now?

Renting has the edge in Cartagena today because mortgage costs have moved much further away from what comparable properties earn in rent, even while home prices keep rising.

The timing is awkward for buyers. DANE’s latest housing-price release showed Colombian new-home prices rising another 2.41% in the second quarter. Cartagena had already been running ahead of the country earlier in the year: its new-home index was up 10.56% year over year in the first quarter, compared with 8.47% nationally.

At the same time, borrowing has become expensive again. Banco de la República is currently holding its policy rate at 12%. Bancolombia, one of the country’s biggest mortgage lenders, now advertises peso mortgages starting at 14.5% effective annually for non-VIS homes. That is a very high hurdle for an apartment whose gross long-term rental yield may be only 5% to 7%.

So buyers face a real trade-off. Cartagena property is still getting more expensive, which makes waiting uncomfortable. Yet financing a purchase today can leave the owner paying far more each month than a renter living in a similar property.

How expensive is it to buy an apartment in Cartagena today?

Buying in Cartagena is already expensive in the neighborhoods most foreign and upper-income buyers look at, with a huge premium attached to the best-known coastal areas.

Colombia Bound currently tracks 3,771 active sale listings across Cartagena and puts the median asking price at about $221,000, or roughly $2,176 per square meter. Those figures are asking prices rather than completed sales, so they tell us where negotiations begin rather than exactly where deals close.

The citywide figure also hides some extreme differences. Bocagrande is currently around $2,788 per square meter, while Crespo is closer to $1,958. Centro reaches more than $5,400 per square meter. A buyer can therefore pay more than twice as much per square meter simply by moving into a different part of Cartagena.

That variation matters more than the city average. Cartagena has cheap property by Miami or Madrid standards, but prime Cartagena is no longer cheap relative to local rents or Colombian financing costs.

Are Cartagena rents actually cheap compared with property prices?

Cartagena rents are expensive in pesos, but they are still fairly cheap compared with what landlords are asking for the underlying apartments.

ClickCasa currently tracks 3,369 rental listings across Cartagena and puts the median apartment rent at COP 3.6 million per month. Half of the market sits roughly between COP 2.5 million and COP 5.2 million.

The premium neighborhoods cost considerably more. Bocagrande is around COP 5 million per month, Manga COP 4.8 million, Crespo COP 4 million and Castillogrande COP 7.5 million.

Those numbers sound high until we compare them with purchase prices. Colombia Bound’s current Bocagrande sample has a $308,000 median asking price and only about a 5.7% gross rental yield. La Boquilla comes in around 5.3%. Even before maintenance, administration, property tax or vacancies, buyers in those areas are paying roughly 17 to 19 years of gross rent upfront.

So renting can feel expensive while still being financially attractive. The apartment itself has become even more expensive than the right to live in it.

Does a mortgage kill the case for buying in Cartagena right now?

For most financed buyers, today’s mortgage rates make renting considerably cheaper than buying the same kind of Cartagena apartment.

Bancolombia currently starts non-VIS mortgages denominated in pesos at 14.5% effective annually. Its UVR option starts at UVR plus 8.3%, which exposes the borrower to inflation-linked changes. Colombians financing a home from abroad can face even higher advertised peso rates.

Take a fairly ordinary example. Colombia Bound currently puts a typical two-bedroom Cartagena home around $211,000. At roughly COP 3,203 per dollar, that is about COP 676 million.

With a 30% down payment, the mortgage would be around COP 473 million. Financing that amount for 20 years at 14.5% effective annually produces a monthly payment of about COP 5.75 million.

The current median Cartagena rent is COP 3.6 million.

That leaves a gap of roughly COP 2.15 million every month before we add home insurance, building administration, property tax, repairs or the opportunity cost of the COP 203 million down payment.

A financed buyer can still come out ahead if the property appreciates strongly for years. But at these rates, appreciation has to rescue the investment rather than simply improve it.

Are Cartagena property prices rising fast enough to make renting a mistake?

Cartagena home prices are currently rising fast, but the recent pace is not enough for us to assume that buying at any price will outperform renting.

DANE recorded a striking change over the past year. Cartagena’s annual new-home inflation was only around 1.4% in early 2025. It reached 8.73% by the end of that year and then 10.56% in the first quarter of 2026.

That acceleration is real.

The longer record is less dramatic. An analysis of DANE data by Fundesarrollo found Cartagena new-home prices rose around 51% between 2020 and 2025, close to the roughly 55% increase recorded nationally. Cartagena did well, but the city was not uniquely outperforming the rest of Colombia throughout that period.

The distinction becomes even more important once inflation enters the picture. Colombian consumer prices are currently rising about 6% annually. Cartagena’s latest 10.56% new-home increase therefore represented meaningful real appreciation, but nowhere near a 10% real return.

We should take recent price growth seriously without projecting it indefinitely. Paying a 14.5% mortgage rate on the assumption that Cartagena homes will keep rising around 10% every year would be an aggressive bet.

What happens if we buy in Cartagena and sell again after five years?

Buying for only five years currently looks weak with a large mortgage because the borrower spends the early years paying enormous amounts of interest while building equity slowly.

Using the same COP 473 million mortgage at 14.5%, the buyer would make roughly COP 345 million of mortgage payments during the first five years.

Only about COP 33 million would reduce the loan balance.

Roughly COP 312 million would go toward interest.

That does not automatically make buying a bad investment because the property may appreciate during those five years. Still, it shows how heavily a short-horizon buyer depends on capital gains. The mortgage itself is barely creating equity during that period.

There are closing costs when buying, further costs when selling, building expenses throughout the ownership period and a potentially long wait for a buyer.

For someone reasonably likely to leave Cartagena within three to five years, we would rent. The numbers currently leave too little room for error.

Does buying Cartagena property with cash change the answer?

Cash makes buying in Cartagena much more credible because it removes the biggest problem in today’s market: expensive mortgage debt.

A cash buyer looking at an apartment producing an 8% gross rental yield is in a very different position from a buyer borrowing at 14.5% to acquire a property yielding 5.5%.

Yet cash does not make the price irrelevant.

Bocagrande currently yields around 5.7% gross according to Colombia Bound. Its median reported administration charge is about $157 per month. Property tax, maintenance and vacancies push the actual yield lower.

There is also an unusually visible opportunity cost right now. With Colombian interest rates still high, peso savings and fixed-income products can offer substantial returns without requiring the investor to own, maintain and eventually sell an apartment.

A cash buyer therefore has room to buy, especially with a long horizon. We would still insist on either a good rental yield, a negotiated purchase price or a strong personal reason for owning the property.

Which Cartagena neighborhoods make buying look better than renting?

Manga and Crespo currently make a stronger financial case for buying than Bocagrande or La Boquilla because buyers receive much more rent for each dollar tied up in the property.

The spread is surprisingly large.

Colombia Bound currently estimates gross rental yields around 8.0% in Manga and 7.5% in Crespo. Bocagrande is closer to 5.7%, La Boquilla 5.3%, El Laguito 6.1% and Castillogrande 6.7%.

At an 8% gross yield, a property's price equals about 12.5 years of gross rent. At 5.3%, the multiple is almost 19 years.

That six-and-a-half-year difference in rent equivalence matters far more to the buy-versus-rent decision than the fact that both apartments happen to sit within Cartagena.

Bocagrande buyers are paying heavily for location, waterfront access, tourism recognition and prestige. Those things can support resale value, but long-term tenants do not compensate owners proportionally for the premium.

The citywide question breaks down pretty quickly once we look neighborhood by neighborhood.

Could Airbnb make buying in Cartagena more profitable than renting?

Airbnb can improve the economics of buying in Cartagena, but it only flips the decision when the apartment genuinely works as a short-term rental business.

Cartagena has a structural advantage here. It is Colombia’s main international leisure destination, and tourism demand supports nightly rates that ordinary long-term tenants would never pay.

That upside comes with a different cost structure. Airbnb owners pay platform fees, utilities, cleaning, furnishing, maintenance, guest management and higher wear. Occupancy also changes through the year. A building that restricts tourist rentals can destroy the strategy entirely.

Commercial operators in Cartagena often advertise potential gross short-term rental yields around the high single digits and, in some cases, above 10%. Those figures can be achievable for good units, but gross Airbnb revenue should never be compared directly with passive long-term rent.

A buyer willing to manage a hospitality business may justify a property that looks mediocre as a long-term rental. Someone simply choosing between living in an apartment and renting one should not assume Airbnb economics will save an overpriced purchase.

Are foreign buyers still getting a cheap exchange rate in Cartagena?

Dollar buyers currently face a much worse entry point than they did a year ago because the Colombian peso has strengthened sharply.

Banco de la República’s latest official exchange rate is about COP 3,203 per dollar.

Around the same point last year, one dollar bought slightly more than COP 4,000. The peso has therefore strengthened by roughly 20% year over year against the dollar.

That difference is huge for a foreign property buyer.

A COP 800 million apartment costs roughly $250,000 at COP 3,203 per dollar. At COP 4,000, the exact same COP 800 million apartment costs $200,000.

Nothing about the building needs to change for the dollar purchase price to rise $50,000.

This is one of the strongest fresh developments affecting foreign buyers. Cartagena property can still be inexpensive compared with major North American or European coastal cities, but the currency discount available during much of the previous year has largely disappeared for now.

How much do closing costs and slow resale hurt Cartagena buyers?

Transaction costs and slow resale make short-term buying in Cartagena noticeably less attractive because owners cannot move in and out of property cheaply.

Bancolombia tells Colombian buyers to budget roughly 1% to 2% of the property value for acquisition expenses on a used home, depending on the deal. Legal estimates that include registration and notarial expenses can run higher in some cases.

Then comes the exit.

Current Colombia Bound listings spend a median of around 202 days on the market in Bocagrande, 222 days in La Boquilla, 252 days in Castillogrande, 256 days in Crespo and 293 days in Manga. Those figures describe active listings rather than completed transactions, so they are imperfect. Overpriced properties also stay online longer.

Even with that caveat, several major neighborhoods sitting above 200 days tells us that Cartagena property is not an instant source of liquidity.

A renter can change neighborhood or leave the city when the lease ends. An owner who suddenly needs the money may have to wait, cut the price or accept both.

That flexibility is worth more today than it looks on a simple rent-versus-mortgage comparison.

Are high mortgage rates actually stopping Colombians from buying homes?

High mortgage rates have not frozen Colombia’s housing market, but the latest lending data show no real financing boom that would force us to rush into Cartagena.

DANE reported COP 6.95 trillion of housing-purchase financing during the second quarter, including COP 5.57 trillion in traditional housing credit and COP 1.39 trillion in housing leasing.

The nominal amount sounds strong.

After adjusting for residential construction prices, however, total housing-finance disbursements were essentially unchanged from a year earlier. Traditional mortgage lending actually subtracted from the annual real growth rate, while leasing provided some support.

That is useful context because rising Cartagena prices might otherwise look like evidence that credit is flooding back into the market. The newest national financing numbers show something more restrained.

Buyers are still buying. Credit is still flowing. We are not looking at the kind of easy-money housing boom where waiting a few months automatically means competing against rapidly expanding mortgage demand.

Could waiting to buy in Cartagena backfire?

Waiting could cost money if Cartagena keeps appreciating and Colombian interest rates eventually fall, but there is no strong reason today to buy a mediocre property simply because rates might become cheaper later.

The bullish scenario is easy to understand. Cartagena prices continue rising, Banco de la República eventually cuts rates, mortgages become cheaper and more buyers return. Someone renting during that period could end up paying a higher purchase price later.

Yet the central bank is currently keeping its policy rate at 12%, with inflation around 6%. At its latest rate decision, four board members wanted to keep rates unchanged while three actually favored another 50-basis-point increase. That is hardly a clear signal that cheap mortgages are about to return.

Longer-term lending rates also depend on government-bond yields and banks’ own funding costs. A small central-bank cut would not automatically turn a 14.5% mortgage into an inexpensive loan.

We would rather risk paying somewhat more later for the right property than lock ourselves into an unattractive deal today out of fear.

How long should we plan to stay in Cartagena before buying?

We would want roughly seven to ten years of expected ownership before preferring a normally priced Cartagena purchase financed with debt today.

There is no magical year when buying suddenly wins. The point is that time gradually fixes several of the buyer's disadvantages.

Closing costs become smaller relative to the total holding period. More mortgage principal gets repaid. Rent has more time to rise. A temporary property-market slowdown matters less. The owner has more chances to benefit from Cartagena's long-term land and housing constraints.

A cash buyer can shorten that required horizon considerably, particularly in a higher-yield neighborhood such as Manga or Crespo.

A heavily financed buyer in Bocagrande should probably think in the opposite direction. With a low gross yield, a high mortgage rate and considerable transaction friction, seven years may still be too short if the property is bought at an aggressive asking price.

For a two- or three-year stay, we see very little reason to buy unless the deal is exceptional.

When does buying in Cartagena actually make more sense than renting?

Buying makes sense in Cartagena today when the buyer plans to stay for years, uses little expensive debt and finds a property whose price makes sense against the rent it could earn.

Those three conditions remove most of the problems we found.

A long holding period gives appreciation time to work. A large down payment avoids financing most of the purchase at double-digit rates. A 7.5% or 8% gross-yield property gives the owner much better underlying economics than a 5.3% one.

Buying can also make sense for reasons that are hard to value precisely. Someone who knows exactly where they want to live, wants to renovate freely, expects to use the home for a decade and has no need for liquidity may reasonably accept a slightly lower financial return.

The purchase becomes much harder to defend when the buyer is borrowing heavily, choosing a low-yield premium neighborhood and hoping recent price appreciation continues at the same speed.

At that point, the buyer is making a leveraged bet on Cartagena property prices.

So, is it better to buy or rent in Cartagena now?

Renting is currently the better choice for most people in Cartagena, especially anyone using a large mortgage, staying less than seven years or looking at expensive coastal neighborhoods such as Bocagrande.

The gap is large enough for us to be fairly confident about that conclusion.

A typical two-bedroom Cartagena home is currently around $211,000 in one large active-listing dataset. Financing 70% of that purchase at Bancolombia's advertised 14.5% starting rate produces a mortgage payment around COP 5.75 million per month. The citywide median apartment rent is about COP 3.6 million.

Ownership then adds administration, maintenance, tax, insurance and transaction costs.

Recent price appreciation is the buyer's strongest counterargument. Cartagena's new-home prices have been rising faster than inflation, and the city continues to benefit from tourism, housing demand and expensive new construction. We would therefore avoid making a bearish call on Cartagena property itself.

The current price-to-rent ratios still favor tenants in several important areas. Bocagrande is around a 5.7% gross yield and La Boquilla roughly 5.3%, while mortgage rates for many buyers sit well into double digits.

Cash buyers get a much closer decision. Manga at roughly 8% gross yield and Crespo around 7.5% already deserve serious consideration, particularly if the buyer can negotiate below the advertised price and intends to hold for a decade.

Our dividing line is straightforward today. Rent when flexibility matters, when a mortgage is necessary or when the property carries a large prestige premium. Buy when the horizon is long, the financing burden is small and the specific apartment produces much better economics than Cartagena's low-yield prime areas.

For the average buyer looking at Cartagena right now, we would rent and keep looking rather than force a purchase.

Who is the author of this content?

THE LATINVESTOR

A team specialized in real estate investing in LATAM countries

We are a team of financial experts, legal professionals, developers, and local real estate specialists dedicated to helping people like you avoid mistakes when investing in real estate in a foreign place, particularly in Cartagena. If you’d like to learn more about us, you can check our presentation page.